What are the ethical debates around permanence vs. biodegradability in PVC nature art?

The use of PVC in nature art sparks significant ethical debates, particularly around the tension between permanence and biodegradability. PVC, a durable synthetic material, ensures artworks withstand the elements, preserving artistic intent for decades. However, its non-biodegradable nature raises environmental concerns, as discarded PVC art contributes to plastic pollution and harms ecosystems.

Proponents of PVC argue that its longevity reduces the need for frequent replacements, lowering overall resource consumption. Critics, however, advocate for biodegradable alternatives, emphasizing the importance of aligning art with ecological responsibility. The debate also touches on artistic legacy—should art endure at the cost of the environment, or should it embrace impermanence as part of its message?

As sustainability gains prominence, artists and audiences alike must weigh the ethical implications of material choices, balancing creative expression with planetary health.