What ethical debates surround cedar harvesting from old-growth forests for art?

The practice of harvesting cedar from old-growth forests for artistic purposes has sparked significant ethical debates. Proponents argue that cedar, with its durability and cultural significance, is irreplaceable for traditional carvings and indigenous art. However, critics highlight the environmental toll, as old-growth forests are vital ecosystems that take centuries to regenerate. The tension between preserving cultural heritage and protecting biodiversity raises questions about sustainable alternatives, such as using reclaimed wood or younger trees. Additionally, indigenous rights and land stewardship often complicate the discussion, as many communities rely on these forests for both material and spiritual needs. Ultimately, the debate underscores the need for balanced solutions that honor artistry while safeguarding our planet's fragile ecosystems.